|
The results of this project will have broad
implications for all stored cereal grains, other
postharvest bulk commodities (e.g., nuts), and all commercial facilities that
process cereal grains, manufacture
cereal products, and store or distribute value-added packaged food
products. 1999)
indicated that insects are managed primarily by chemical treatments, and IPM
practices such as storage hygiene, aeration,
grain turning, sampling and monitoring of grain for insects, temperature,
and moisture are under-utilized, resulting in poor insect control and
deterioration of grain due to insects and
molds.
The level of IPM and pesticide use in stored
wheat varies among the U.S. wheat-growing regions
(Kenkel et al. 1992, Martin et al. 1997). This is related to the environmental
conditions existing in these various
regions, different insect species associated with wheat in different wheat-growing
regions, susceptibility of different wheat classes to insects and time wheat is
in storage.
No one crop can be isolated and described
with regard to acreage affected. Stored grain is
described by volume, in bushels, and thus we need to estimate what percentage of
these stored bushels might be treated with
OP grain protectants in a year. For example, the typical U.S. harvest
for hard red winter wheat (HRWW), the raw commodity used for production of flour
for bread baking, is about 1.2 billion
bushels annually and about 900 million bushels of that is stored at
commercial grain elevators for 1 or more months. A 1992 survey of pest
management practices at 1020 HRWW grain
elevators in the U.S. (Kenkel et al. 1992) found that OP grain protectants
were used predominantly on wheat stored in large steel bins (which are difficult
to fumigate), representing about 40% of the
stored crop, or 360 million bushels. Of elevator managers
surveyed, 30% reported treating grain in steel bins with malathion while 23%
reported using chlorpyrifos methyl. Thus,
about 190 million bushels of HRWW (produced on about 4.7 million
acres of land) was treated with OP insecticides directly. This figure represents
about 15% of the entire HRWW harvest for
that year. This 15% value for amount of crop treated may be
conservative. A 1996 survey of IPM practices for northern U.S. and Canadian
stored wheat (Martin et al. 1997) reported
that 48.5% of farmers and 45% of elevators in the U.S. used OP grain
protectants, primarily malathion and chlorpyrifos-methyl, on stored wheat.
Assuming that 15% of other stored grains
(e.g. corn, rice, oats, barley, etc.) are typically treated with OP grain
protectants, a significant proportion of stored
commodities will be left untreated if these labels are
cancelled.
The NASS survey (NASS 1999) of elevator
managers indicated that 11.6% of wheat stored
at the elevators was fumigated with phosphine, 1.4% was treated with
chlorpyrifosmethyl, and 1.5% with malathion.
Assuming a cost of $ 2.50/bushel of wheat and a cost of 1 cent/bushel
each for phosphine and malathion treatment, and 2 cents/bushel for
chlorpyrifosmethyl treatment, the total
annual estimated costs of pesticides used on wheat would be $5.7 million.
These costs do not include costs of pesticides applied to empty bins, costs of
pesticides used on farm-stored wheat, costs
of aeration/sanitation, labor costs, costs associated with resistant
development in insects, quantitative and qualitative losses of grain due to
insect infestation, and discounts applied
for delivering insect-infested grain at the time of sale.
The use of
postharvest pesticides, especially the OPs on stored corn and other small grains
(e.g., barley) is less than that reported for wheat (Harein et al. 1985, Gardner
et al. 1987, Willson and Eisley 1994). In
some stored products such as popping corn and malting barley, the presence
of pesticide residues is deemed unacceptable by the industry utlilizing these
products. Therefore, effective alternatives
to OPs are needed for such special situations. |
|